Can Nigerian Churches Learn From The Mistakes of the American Churches?

I’ve been reading a good deal of early Christian literature lately, particularly the lives of the early church fathers and the saints. I’ve found myself drawn to a genre called hagiography, essentially biographies of saints, often written by people who knew them or lived close to their time. I’ve been reading about Anthony the Great, Martin of Tours, Paul the Hermit, Ambrose, and Benedict.

What strikes me about these accounts is the seriousness with which these men approached their faith. Many surrendered comfortable lives to pursue something they considered infinitely more important. Their biographies describe extraordinary devotion to prayer and a willingness to endure hardship for the sake of their convictions. Reading about them has made me think about the contemporary American church and how far removed our priorities can be from theirs.

Consider the growth of Christianity during its first few centuries. According to historical estimates cited by Robert Wilken, a professor of history at the University of Virginia, the Christian population of the Roman Empire grew from approximately 10,000 people in 100 AD to around 200,000 by 200 AD. By 250 AD, the number had surpassed one million. Fifty years later, in 300 AD, it had reached approximately six million.

That’s a 600-fold increase in just two centuries.

These Christians were largely poor and uneducated. They lived under an empire that periodically persecuted them and offered them no political influence. This extraordinary growth took place before the end of official Roman persecution in 313 AD. They had very few of the advantages we associate with successful religious movements today yet changed the world.

I’ve often wondered what explains that growth. The answer, I suspect, has everything to do with the way these people understood their faith. Christianity was the organizing principle of their lives. Their commitment to Jesus influenced how they treated other people and what they considered worth pursuing. They were willing to sacrifice their own interests because they believed they had discovered something of immeasurable value.

The contrast with American Christianity is stark.

We live in one of the wealthiest societies in human history. American Christians enjoy freedoms and material advantages that the early church could not have imagined. Yet so much of our religious conversation revolves around the possibility of losing those advantages. We worry about political influence and cultural standing. We spend enormous amounts of time discussing the moral failures of secular society while giving surprisingly little attention to the condition of our own religious communities.

I think it’s time to remember.

The problem of religious respectability

American Christianity has become remarkably comfortable with the appearance of righteousness. We have developed a recognizable religious identity, complete with its own vocabulary and cultural affiliations. For many people, identifying as a Christian has come to mean belonging to a particular social and political community.

The problem is that these affiliations tell us very little about whether someone is actually living according to the teachings of Jesus.

Consider the ordinary habits of American Christians. We spend like our secular neighbors. We romance like them, and we divorce like them. Political disagreements make us jerks. Then we remain remarkably confident in our ability to identify the moral shortcomings of everyone else.

This is where I think the younger generation is departing. They hear Christians talking about the guy who taught us to love our neighbors, our enemies, and complete strangers, and then watch us defending its own interests.

Jesus taught forgiveness, but resentment has become a familiar feature of Christian political and social life. His teachings on generosity should make us unusually willing to give away what we possess. But we don’t. A religious community that demands moral accountability from the surrounding culture while showing so little evidence of its own transformation is utterly unconvincing.

We have become skilled at defending Christianity as an institution as a substitute for living like Christ.

The illusion of being a good person

American Christianity has absorbed the idea that being a Christian largely means being a respectable person. We try to behave ourselves and avoid obvious moral failures. We attend church and maintain a reasonably decent reputation. Somewhere in the back of our minds, we imagine that these things will count in our favor when we eventually stand before God.

The Christian message says instead that we can’t manufacture our own righteousness or earn God’s favor through a lifetime of respectable behavior. Our relationship with God rests entirely on what Jesus has done for us.

That realization ought to produce humility. When I understand that my forgiveness is a gift, I have very little reason to congratulate myself for being morally superior to someone else. Recognizing the depth of my own failures should make me considerably more patient with the failures of others.

But we are a religious culture that values being right more than demonstrating love.

Knowing that Jesus has taken the weight of our failures upon himself gives us the freedom to stop constructing an impressive religious identity. Our lives can become expressions of gratitude rather than attempts to earn approval.

Our attachments

The other problem I see in American Christianity is our attachment to material comfort.

Society measures success through accumulation. A larger home or a more impressive career becomes evidence that our lives are progressing. Financial security somewhere along the way becomes an organizing principle of our existence.

The biographies of Anthony the Great and Martin of Tours describe men who deliberately surrendered the advantages available to them. Their decisions were grounded in a conviction that their lives belonged to Christ. They regarded the pursuit of spiritual maturity as considerably more important than acquiring the comforts of ordinary society.

Their example became influential throughout the Christian world. Monastic communities emerged across the Mediterranean and eventually throughout Europe. These communities helped preserve Christian learning and established institutions that would shape Western civilization for centuries.

The early church also grew through ordinary Christians whose faith had profound consequences for their neighbors. Their willingness to care for the sick and vulnerable became a distinctive feature of Christian communities. During periods of epidemic disease, Christians sometimes remained to care for the afflicted when others fled. Their behavior gave outsiders a tangible reason to take their faith seriously.

We need pastors who are willing to establish churches in places where Christianity has little presence. I’ve occasionally heard about ministers who have asked where the least Christian areas of America might be and moved there. Others have looked for communities experiencing rapid population growth where a new congregation might flourish.

Imagine what might happen if more Christians approached their faith with that kind of ambition. We might devote more attention to the needs of people who have never encountered a meaningful Christian community. We might begin to think of our resources as something entrusted to us for the benefit of others.

Instead, much of our religious conversation revolves around preserving the life we already enjoy.

Perhaps the most revealing part of this situation is that we rarely recognise how much we resemble the culture we criticise. Our ambitions are largely the same. Our understanding of success is largely the same. Even our anxieties often revolve around the same things.

Recovering the Christian life

I keep returning to those early Christian population figures. Ten thousand people became six million in two centuries. They accomplished this while living under persecution.

What did they understand that we have forgotten?

They understood that Christianity requires a fundamental reorientation of the whole person. Faith in Jesus was supposed to change the way someone approached the world. It redefined success. People could see the difference in the way Christians treated their neighbors and responded to suffering. The faith became visible through the ordinary decisions of everyday life.

The American church has become distracted. The answer to the decline of American Christianity has nothing to do with a political victory or a more sophisticated marketing campaign. It begins with Christians taking seriously the life Jesus actually taught us to live.

I would love to see a church whose members are known for their generosity. I would love to see Christians who are willing to forgive people who have treated them terribly. I would love to see communities where strangers are welcomed and the vulnerable are genuinely cared for. These are the qualities that made the early Christian communities distinctive, and they remain the qualities that ought to distinguish us today.

The American church has spent a great deal of time worrying about what might happen if it loses its influence over American culture. Perhaps we should spend more time asking why our influence has become so unconvincing in the first place. The early Christians attracted the attention of an entire empire.

We have access to their writings and the testimony of their lives. Their example is remarkably clear. I think it’s time we remembered.

Print your tickets