How Did Life Begin?

One of the world’s leading synthetic chemists argues that scientists can’t explain how nonliving chemicals became living organisms.

How did life begin? His answer is God.

As a student of the philosophy of science, I like the question. I remember years ago hearing it posed, and the quickish Richard Dawkins saying, “We’re working on it.” Given that he was a zoologist, he wasn’t doing anything of the sort.

Scientists understand an extraordinary amount about how living organism’s function. We can sequence DNA, manipulate genes, and investigate the chemistry of individual cells, but we still lack a comprehensive explanation of how the first living system emerged from nonliving matters. Abiogenesis.

It’s the subject of considerable research. It is also the subject of criticism from James Tour, a professor of chemistry at Rice University who argues that scientists have significantly underestimated the chemical difficulties involved.

Tour is not a casual commentator on the subject. He holds a Ph.D. in synthetic organic chemistry from Purdue University and completed postdoctoral research at Stanford. He joined Rice University, where he is the T. T. and W. F. Chao Professor of Chemistry. His research focuses on synthetic chemistry, nanotechnology, and molecular materials. He has published more than 700 scientific papers and holds numerous patents. If you’ve never listened to him, his lectures are on YouTube. He’s animated and interesting, accessible to the layman but worthy of the informed scientist.

His expertise is particularly relevant because his research involves constructing complex molecules through chemical reactions. He understands firsthand what it takes to make complicated organic structures. And nothing explains how chemistry could create biology.

*God clears his throat. *

His central argument is blunt. Demonstrating that individual biological molecules can form under laboratory conditions is not the same as explaining how those molecules assembled into the first living organism.

The problem of making the ingredients

Life requires several kinds of molecules working together. Proteins perform chemical reactions, DNA and RNA carry genetic information, carbohydrates provide important structural and chemical functions, and lipids help form cell membranes.

Scientists have investigated how many of these molecules might have formed naturally on the early Earth, but Tour argues that the proposed chemical pathways encounter insurmountable obstacles.

Consider proteins. They are constructed from amino acids, joined together through peptide bonds. Forming these bonds in water is chemically challenging. Water can break peptide bonds through hydrolysis. Chemists can only overcome such problems through controlled conditions, catalysts, activating agents, and purification techniques. In other words, only by intelligent design.

Tour asks how these reactions could have occurred in nature without a chemist carefully controlling the process.

*God yawns. *

Producing a small quantity of peptide in a laboratory is one thing. Demonstrating that the same chemistry could have produced useful quantities of proteins in a prebiotic environment has proven impossible.

The RNA problem

One of the most popular explanations for life’s early development is the RNA World Hypothesis.

RNA is particularly interesting because it can perform two important functions. It carries genetic information, and certain RNA molecules, ribozymes, can catalyze chemical reactions. This makes RNA a possible candidate for an early biological system that existed before modern DNA and proteins.

But RNA itself is chemically complicated. It consists of repeating units called nucleotides, each containing sugar, a phosphate group, and a nitrogenous base. These components must be produced and joined together in the correct arrangement. The resulting nucleotides must then connect to form RNA chains.

No one can explain how they formed, assembled, and eventually developed the ability to replicate information. A complete, experimentally demonstrated pathway from simple prebiotic chemicals to a self-replicating RNA system is unreachable.

Tour argues that this gap is ignored when the RNA World Hypothesis is presented as an explanation. Because modern science is ideologically driven.

The problem of molecular handedness

Another challenge involves a property called chirality. Some molecules exist in two forms that are mirror images of one another, much like left and right hands. Amino acids, for example, can exist in L and D forms. Modern biological proteins overwhelmingly use L-amino acids, while biological sugars, including the ribose in RNA, predominantly use D forms.

This consistency matters because biological molecules interact through highly specific three-dimensional structures. The wrong molecular orientation can interfere with those interactions. Ordinary chemical reactions produce mixtures of both forms. How did early biological chemistry develop the strong molecular preferences found in living organisms?

Assembling a living system

Tour’s most important argument concerns the difference between producing biological molecules and producing life.

A living cell is not simply a collection of chemicals. It’s an integrated system. DNA stores information. RNA participates in translating that information. Proteins perform chemical reactions. Membranes maintain the internal environment. Energy systems power the processes that keep the cell functioning. These components depend on one another.

Producing amino acids does not produce proteins. Producing proteins does not produce a functioning cell. And producing all the necessary molecular ingredients does not explain how they became an organized system capable of maintaining and reproducing.

Tour argues that this is the central problem that origin-of-life research cannot solve.

Is Tour, right?

Those who hate the implications are working hard to avoid them.

Tour is an outspoken Christian, and his criticisms have attracted attention partly because of his religious beliefs. But his scientific objections must be evaluated on their chemical merits, independently of his theological conclusions. He has the requisite scientific credentials to make his case.

The fact that scientists have not yet explained the origin of life points to supernatural intervention. Assuming that a natural explanation must eventually be found is simply naturalism-of-the-gaps.

What makes Tour’s criticism incisive is that he exposes a distinction that is lost in popular accounts of the subject. Explaining how the ingredients of life form is not the same as explaining how life itself began.

We know a great deal about the chemistry of living organisms. We know nothing about how that chemistry first became biology.

And that remains one place where science’s questions point to theology’s answers.

Print your tickets