You can believe that Jesus was a good man, a misguided religious fanatic, or even a complete fraud.
But there’s one thing you probably shouldn’t believe about him.
That he never existed.
Recently, one of my regular readers left a comment on an article that took me by surprise. He’s a staunch atheist who has been reading and commenting on my work for quite some time. He’s also intelligent, thoughtful, and consistently respectful, even when we disagree. I enjoy our exchanges. In fact, I wish more Christians and atheists could disagree with each other the way we do.
Anyway, he said something that made me stop and read his comment twice.
“There is no ‘historical evidence for his existence.’ Jesus of Nazareth is only mentioned in the New Testament documents which are propaganda/theological documents, not historical documents. There is no physical evidence whatsoever, although there are enough claimed pieces of the cross he was supposedly crucified on to create another Noah-style ark.”
He’s got a point about the amount of wood supposedly recovered from the cross of Christ over the centuries. I’m surprised someone hasn’t started selling it by the truckload at Home Depot.
But his claim that there is no historical evidence for Jesus? That’s where he lost me.
Look, I understand why an atheist might reject Christianity. There are plenty of reasons to question the supernatural claims made about Jesus, and I’ve spent a fair bit of time questioning some of them myself. Whether Jesus performed miracles, rose from the dead, or was God walking around in human skin are all matters of considerable debate.
But whether Jesus actually existed is a different question altogether. And it’s one that historians, including historians who don’t believe in God, have been investigating for a very long time.
Here’s what surprised me most. The idea that Jesus never existed is actually a fringe position in mainstream historical scholarship. Even Bart Ehrman, one of the world’s best-known New Testament scholars, who happens to be an agnostic and a rather outspoken critic of traditional Christianity, has written an entire book explaining why the evidence points overwhelmingly toward a historical Jesus.
And he’s hardly alone.
Of course, we don’t have Jesus’ birth certificate, his fingerprints, or a photograph of him standing outside the local synagogue. But we’re talking about a Jewish peasant who lived two thousand years ago, not someone applying for a passport. The fact that nobody has dug up a sandal with his name stitched into it isn’t particularly surprising.
What we do have are ancient writings, including sources that have nothing to do with the Bible, which give us good reasons to believe that Jesus of Nazareth was a real person.
So, I want to take my reader’s comment seriously and look at the evidence. What do we actually know about Jesus outside the Bible? How reliable are the sources? And is there any merit to the claim that he was invented by the early Christians?
I think it’s time we settled this.
Jesus was real. And you don’t need to be a Christian to recognise it.
Let’s Throw Out the Bible for a Moment
I’ll tell you what. For the sake of those who don’t believe the Bible has any historical value, let’s put it aside for a moment. We’ll pretend the New Testament doesn’t exist and see what we’re left with.
Now, I should point out that dismissing the Bible as a historical source simply because it’s a religious document is a pretty difficult position to defend. Historians don’t generally throw out ancient writings because their authors had religious convictions or were trying to persuade their readers of something. If they did, we’d have to discard an enormous amount of what we know about the ancient world.
The New Testament isn’t a single document, either. It’s a collection of writings produced by different authors at different times, and historians examine those writings just as they would any other ancient source. They ask when they were written, who wrote them, what the authors were trying to accomplish, and whether their claims can be corroborated. The fact that a document contains theology doesn’t automatically mean it contains no history. Otherwise, we’d have to conclude that religious people are incapable of recording actual events, which would be a rather strange argument to make.
But let’s leave all that for another day.
Suppose we had never discovered a single copy of the New Testament. Suppose Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, and every letter attributed to Paul had disappeared from history. Would we have any reason to believe that a Jewish preacher named Jesus lived in first-century Palestine?
As it turns out, we would.
There are references to Jesus in ancient Jewish and Roman literature written by people who weren’t Christians, weren’t particularly sympathetic to Christianity, and certainly weren’t trying to convince anyone that Jesus was the Son of God. Some of these references are more reliable than others, and a few have been the subject of considerable scholarly debate. We’ll get to that.
But the claim that Jesus is mentioned only in the New Testament is simply incorrect.
And perhaps the best place to start is with a Jewish historian who had no particular reason to promote Christianity.
- Josephus: The Jewish Historian Who Mentioned Jesus
The first person worth looking at is Flavius Josephus, a Jewish historian born around AD 37, not long after the death of Jesus. Josephus had quite a colourful life. He initially fought against the Romans during the Jewish revolt, but after being captured, he eventually ended up in Rome enjoying the patronage of the Roman emperors. It was there that he wrote extensively about Jewish history, including a twenty-volume work called Antiquities of the Jews, completed around AD 93–94. And it’s in this work that we find two references to Jesus.
The first appears in Book 20, Chapter 9, where Josephus describes an incident involving the Jewish high priest Ananus, who arranged for a man named James and several others to be executed by stoning.
Here’s how Josephus identifies James:
“The brother of Jesus, who was called Christ, whose name was James.”
That’s rather interesting, isn’t it? Josephus mentions Jesus almost in passing, simply to identify another person. He doesn’t launch into a sermon or attempt to convince his readers that Jesus was the Messiah. In fact, the whole incident is about the high priest’s abuse of authority. Jesus is barely relevant to the story.
And that’s partly why historians take this reference seriously. Unlike another, more controversial passage we’ll get to in a moment, this reference is widely accepted by scholars as authentic. Josephus appears to be referring to Jesus as someone his readers might recognise, without expressing any particular religious devotion to him.
The second reference is considerably more famous, and a little more complicated.
In Book 18, Chapter 3, Josephus describes a man named Jesus who attracted followers, performed what the text calls extraordinary deeds, and was condemned to crucifixion under Pontius Pilate. The passage also says that Jesus was the Messiah and appeared alive again three days after his death.
Now, hold on a minute.
Josephus was Jewish, and there’s no convincing evidence that he ever became a Christian. So why would he suddenly start declaring Jesus to be the Messiah and affirming his resurrection?
That’s precisely the problem historians have wrestled with for centuries.
The passage, known as the Testimonium Flavianum, has almost certainly been affected by the way it was transmitted through Christian scribes, according to many scholars. Some believe Josephus originally wrote a shorter, more neutral account of Jesus that was subsequently embellished by Christian copyists. Others argue that the entire passage was inserted later.
Interestingly, the debate has recently taken another turn. In 2025, Oxford University Press published historian T. C. Schmidt’s Josephus and Jesus: New Evidence for the One Called Christ, in which Schmidt argues that the passage is substantially authentic and that modern scholars have misunderstood some of its supposedly Christian language. His conclusions are significant, although they certainly haven’t ended the scholarly debate.
But here’s what matters for our purposes.
Even if we set aside the disputed passage in Book 18 entirely, we’re still left with Josephus referring to James as the brother of Jesus, who was called Christ. It’s a reference from a non-Christian Jewish historian, writing toward the end of the first century, identifying Jesus as a historical person.
Does this prove that Jesus was divine? Of course not. Does it establish that he performed miracles or rose from the dead? Nope. But it gives us something rather important: a reference to Jesus in a Jewish historical work written outside the Christian movement.
And Josephus wasn’t the only ancient historian to mention him.
- Tacitus: The Roman Historian
Next up is Cornelius Tacitus, a Roman historian and senator who lived from around AD 56 to 120. He’s generally regarded as one of Rome’s most important historians, and his writings are still studied extensively today. Around AD 116, Tacitus was working on his Annals, a history of the Roman Empire covering the reigns of several emperors, including Nero.
And it’s while discussing Nero that Tacitus makes a rather interesting reference to Jesus.
In AD 64, a massive fire swept through Rome, destroying much of the city. Rumors circulated that Nero himself had been responsible, and according to Tacitus in Annals 15.44, the emperor decided to shift the blame onto a relatively unpopular religious group known as the Christians.
Tacitus wasn’t particularly fond of Christians himself. He described Christianity as a destructive superstition and spoke about its followers with considerable contempt. But while explaining who these Christians were, he also explained where their movement had come from.
He wrote that Christus, from whom the Christians took their name, had suffered the death penalty during the reign of Emperor Tiberius, at the hands of Pontius Pilate.
That’s a pretty significant detail. We have a Roman historian, writing roughly eighty years after Jesus’ death, identifying the founder of Christianity as someone who had been executed under a named Roman official during the reign of a named emperor.
Tacitus had no interest in promoting Christianity. As far as he was concerned, it was an unpleasant religious movement that had spread from Judea all the way to Rome. Yet he had no difficulty identifying its founder as an actual historical person.
And that’s what makes his reference so valuable. Tacitus wasn’t writing a biography of Jesus, and he certainly wasn’t trying to establish the historical foundations of Christianity. He was writing about Nero, the fire of Rome, and the emperor’s treatment of a religious group he disliked. Jesus appears in the account because Tacitus needed to explain where that group originated.
So now we have a Jewish historian mentioning Jesus and his brother James, and a Roman historian placing Jesus’ execution during the reign of Tiberius.
For someone who supposedly left no trace in the historical record, Jesus is proving rather difficult to get rid of.
- Pliny the Younger: The Roman Governor Who Hated Christians
Our next witness is Pliny the Younger, a Roman lawyer, politician, and provincial governor who found himself dealing with a rather irritating problem around AD 112. Christianity was spreading throughout the province of Bithynia-Pontus, in what is now modern-day Turkey, and Pliny wasn’t quite sure what to do about it.
So, he wrote a letter to Emperor Trajan asking for advice.
In Letter 10.96, Pliny explains that he’d been interrogating people accused of being Christians. If they admitted to being Christians, he would ask them again, threatening punishment. Those who persisted could be executed, while those who denied their faith and demonstrated loyalty to the Roman gods were allowed to go free.
What makes the letter interesting is what Pliny discovered when he questioned the Christians about their beliefs and practices. According to his account, they gathered together before dawn on a particular day of the week and sang hymns to Christ, whom they worshipped as a god. They also pledged not to steal, commit adultery, lie, or betray anyone’s trust.
Pliny was so determined to uncover what these Christians were up to that he even had two female slaves, whom the Christians called deaconesses, tortured for information. After all that, he couldn’t find evidence of any particularly sinister activities. He concluded that Christianity was simply an excessive and misguided superstition.
The emperor’s response, preserved in Letter 10.97, was to tell Pliny that Christians shouldn’t be actively hunted down, but those who were formally accused and refused to renounce their faith should still be punished.
Now, Pliny doesn’t tell us much about the life of Jesus himself. His account is concerned with Christians rather than their founder. But it does establish something worth paying attention to. By the beginning of the second century, communities devoted to Christ were well established in the Roman Empire, gathering regularly for worship and attracting enough attention that a provincial governor felt compelled to write to the emperor about them.
And these weren’t Christian documents written to promote the faith. They were official Roman correspondence between a governor and his emperor, discussing how to deal with a religious movement they regarded as a nuisance.
So, within roughly eighty years of Jesus’ death, we have Roman officials discussing communities that worshipped him, Jewish and Roman historians referring to him by name, and an account of his execution under Pontius Pilate.
- Lucian: The Greek Who Thought Christians Were Gullible Fools
By the middle of the second century, Christianity had attracted the attention of another writer who wasn’t particularly impressed with the movement. His name was Lucian of Samosata, a Greek-speaking satirist who made a career out of mocking religious beliefs, philosophers, and just about anyone else he thought deserved a good roasting.
Lucian wasn’t a Christian, and he certainly wasn’t interested in defending Christianity. In fact, if he’d been alive today, I suspect he would have had a rather successful career making fun of televangelists.
Sometime after AD 165, Lucian wrote a work called The Passing of Peregrinus, in which he ridiculed a philosopher named Peregrinus who had briefly become involved with the Christian community. According to Lucian, Peregrinus discovered that Christians were remarkably generous toward their fellow believers, particularly those who were imprisoned for their faith. He also discovered that this generosity made them rather easy to exploit.
Lucian clearly thought the whole thing was ridiculous. But in the middle of his account, he made an interesting observation about the man these Christians worshipped.
He described their founder as someone who had been crucified in Palestine for introducing a new religious movement. Later, in section 13 of the same work, he referred to him as a crucified teacher whose followers continued to live according to his teachings.
Think about the significance of that. Lucian was writing more than a century after Jesus’ death, from outside the Christian community, and he understood Christianity to have originated with a teacher who had been executed in Palestine.
What makes Lucian particularly entertaining is that he had almost as much contempt for Christians as some modern internet atheists do. He thought their beliefs were foolish, their expectations of immortality absurd, and their willingness to share their possessions an open invitation for con artists.
Yet even Lucian didn’t suggest that the person they worshipped was imaginary.
And that’s what interests me about these ancient accounts. Josephus, Tacitus, Pliny, and Lucian came from different backgrounds, wrote for different audiences, and had different reasons for mentioning Christianity. None was trying to establish the truth of the Christian faith.
Yet their writings give us a picture of a movement that emerged around a Jewish figure associated with Palestine, whose execution became central to the identity of his followers.
We can argue about what those followers believed and whether they were right to believe it. But the suggestion that Jesus appears nowhere outside Christian scripture is becoming increasingly difficult to sustain.
- Celsus: The Man Who Tried to Take Christianity Apart
If you think modern atheists can be harsh on Christianity, you should meet Celsus.
Celsus was a Greek philosopher who, sometime in the late second century, wrote a scathing attack on Christianity called The True Doctrine. He considered Christian beliefs irrational, accused Christians of being gullible, and was particularly unimpressed by their claims about Jesus. He had clearly spent some time examining Christianity because his criticisms were surprisingly detailed.
Unfortunately, his original book hasn’t survived. However, we know a great deal about what he wrote because a Christian theologian named Origen decided to respond to him in the third century. Origen wrote an extensive rebuttal called Against Celsus, preserving substantial portions of his opponent’s arguments in the process. You can read it here.
And some of those arguments are pretty wild.
Celsus disputed the virgin birth and presented an alternative story about Jesus’ origins. According to the account he circulated, Mary had become pregnant through an affair with a Roman soldier named Panthera, and Jesus was subsequently born out of wedlock. He also claimed that Jesus had travelled to Egypt, where he learned magical arts, before returning home and using those skills to convince people he possessed supernatural powers.
You can find these accusations in Against Celsus, Book 1, Chapters 28 and 32.
I can only imagine how well that went down with the early Christians.
Of course, there’s no good reason to accept Celsus’ alternative account of Jesus’ birth as historical fact. He was deliberately attacking Christian claims, and his version of events was every bit as polemical as the religious arguments he was trying to dismantle.
But there’s something fascinating about the nature of his attack. Celsus disputed where Jesus came from, who his father was, how he acquired his supposed miraculous powers, and whether his followers had been deceived. He was prepared to challenge virtually everything Christianity taught about its founder.
Yet the Jesus he attacked was a man who had actually lived.
Celsus wasn’t interested in arguing that Jesus had been invented. His argument was that Jesus was an ordinary human being whose followers had exaggerated his significance and turned him into something he wasn’t.
That distinction is worth considering. Some of the earliest critics of Christianity were perfectly willing to accuse Jesus of deception, question his parentage, and ridicule his followers. But their arguments generally proceeded on the assumption that there had been a real person behind the movement.
And Celsus wasn’t some obscure character whose writings have only recently been discovered. His attack was substantial enough that one of early Christianity’s most influential thinkers devoted an entire book to answering him.
By the late second century, people were already having fierce arguments about who Jesus really was.
The argument was over what to make of him, rather than whether anybody had made him up in the first place.
- A Few More Ancient Writers Worth Mentioning
Believe it or not, there are still a few more ancient writers who deserve a mention. Some Christian apologists, including Lee Strobel in The Case for Christ, have devoted considerable attention to these lesser-known sources. And while they don’t all tell us something new about Jesus himself, they help us understand just how widely Christianity had spread and how much attention it was attracting.
Take Suetonius, for example. He was a Roman historian who wrote The Lives of the Twelve Caesars around AD 120. In his account of Emperor Claudius, Suetonius mentions that the emperor expelled Jews from Rome because they were causing disturbances associated with someone called Chrestus. Many historians believe this was a reference to Christ and disagreements about him within Rome’s Jewish community, although the identification isn’t certain.
Suetonius also mentions Christians in his biography of Nero, describing them as followers of a new and troublesome superstition. He doesn’t seem particularly interested in what they believed. As with Tacitus, Christianity was simply another religious nuisance that Rome had to deal with.
Then there’s Mara bar Serapion, a Syrian writer who sent a letter to his son while imprisoned by the Romans. In the letter, he reflects on the unfortunate fate of several great thinkers who were killed by their own people, including Socrates and Pythagoras. He also asks what the Jews gained by executing their “wise king,” whose teachings continued to live on after his death.
You can read the surviving letter here. Jesus isn’t mentioned by name, but many scholars believe he’s the person Mara had in mind. The exact date of the letter is uncertain, with estimates ranging from the late first century to several centuries later. Still, the reference to an executed Jewish teacher whose influence survived his death is an intriguing one.
Nobody’s Asking Whether Socrates Was Real
Here’s what I find strange about the whole debate over whether Jesus existed. We happily accept the existence of all sorts of people from ancient history without giving it a second thought. Nobody finishes reading about Socrates and immediately heads to the internet to argue that the whole man was invented. We simply accept that Socrates existed, that Alexander the Great conquered half the known world, and that Spartacus led a slave rebellion against Rome.
And yet, mention Jesus, and suddenly people start demanding his birth certificate.
Take Socrates, for example. He’s one of the most influential philosophers in human history. His ideas helped shape Western philosophy, and his name is familiar to practically anyone who has studied the subject. Yet Socrates never wrote a single book. Everything we know about him comes from other people, particularly Plato, Xenophon, and the playwright Aristophanes.
Interestingly, those writers don’t always agree about what Socrates was like. Plato portrays him as a brilliant philosophical thinker, while Aristophanes makes him look like a ridiculous intellectual who spends his days talking nonsense. Historians have spent centuries trying to untangle the historical Socrates from the various portraits left behind by people who knew him or wrote about him. There’s even a term for it: the Socratic problem.
But here’s the thing. Nobody needs to establish that Socrates existed before they can begin discussing his philosophy. His existence is generally taken for granted, even though historians continue debating what he actually said and believed.
Or consider Spartacus, the gladiator who led a massive slave rebellion against the Roman Republic between 73 and 71 BC. We’ve all heard of him, and most of us probably picture Kirk Douglas shouting, “I am Spartacus!” His rebellion was a significant event in Roman history, yet the two most substantial surviving accounts were written by Plutarch and Appian more than a century later.
Imagine someone arguing that Spartacus never existed because the most detailed surviving accounts of his rebellion were written generations after his death. Or that the writers had political and cultural biases, so their accounts must be dismissed as propaganda. We would rightly regard that as a peculiar way of doing history.
Then there’s Alexander the Great, who died in 323 BC after creating one of the largest empires the ancient world had ever seen. Some of our most important surviving written accounts of his life were composed centuries after he died. Arrian, for example, wrote his history of Alexander’s campaigns roughly four hundred years after the events themselves, drawing upon earlier sources that have since disappeared.
Now, Alexander also left substantial archaeological evidence, including coins and inscriptions, so his historical record is considerably richer than that of Jesus. But that only reinforces the point that different historical figures leave behind different kinds of evidence. A king who conquered empires is naturally going to leave a bigger footprint than a Jewish preacher who spent a few years teaching in Galilee.
And that’s what makes the evidence for Jesus so interesting.
Jesus wasn’t an emperor, a general, or a wealthy aristocrat. He was a Jewish teacher from an obscure province of the Roman Empire who, according to our earliest accounts, spent a relatively short period travelling around teaching before being executed by crucifixion. He wasn’t the sort of person the Roman authorities would ordinarily bother recording for posterity.
Yet here we are, two thousand years later, with references to him in Jewish and Roman historical writings, along with accounts of the movement that emerged after his death.
I’m not suggesting that the historical evidence for Jesus is identical to the evidence for Socrates, Spartacus, or Alexander. It isn’t. What I’m suggesting is that we should approach the question of Jesus’ existence using the same basic historical methods we apply to everyone else.
We don’t dismiss Socrates because his followers wrote about him. We don’t dismiss Spartacus because our surviving accounts were written long after his death. And we certainly don’t pretend that Alexander never existed because some of the stories told about him became increasingly legendary.
So why would we throw out the historical existence of Jesus simply because the people who followed him eventually made extraordinary religious claims about who he was?
You can disagree with those claims all you like. You can question the miracles, reject the resurrection, and argue that Christianity has misunderstood its own founder. I’ve spent plenty of time doing some of that myself.
But the claim that Jesus never existed is a different proposition altogether. And when we examine the historical evidence using the same standards we apply to other figures from antiquity, there’s very little reason to doubt that he was real.